Skip to main content

Carrie Underwood Reportedly Considering Leaving ‘American Idol’ – Says It Might Not Be Worth the Pain

Carrie Underwood Reportedly Considering Leaving ‘American Idol’ – Says It Might Not Be Worth the Pain

By Priyanshu Gurrani – June 3, 2025


Carrie Underwood may be having second thoughts about her new role on American Idol. The country music superstar joined the hit talent show earlier this year for its 23rd season, stepping in as a judge after pop icon Katy Perry’s exit. But just a few months in, reports suggest Underwood is seriously considering leaving the show — and fans are shocked.

A Full-Circle Moment Turned Sour?

Underwood, now 42, got her big break on American Idol back in 2005 when she won Season 4. Two decades later, she returned to the franchise as a judge alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan. At first, it seemed like a perfect fit — a former winner mentoring a new generation of hopefuls.

However, not all fans were impressed. Over recent months, Underwood has faced backlash online for what some viewers describe as a “boring” presence on the show. Others have criticized her for not offering enough constructive criticism to contestants.

According to a source who spoke with Star Magazine, Underwood is uncertain about returning for another season.

> “She’s let bosses know she’s not 100 percent sure,” the insider claimed. “It’s been a bumpy ride.”



Underpaid Compared to Katy Perry?

What’s adding to Underwood’s hesitation? Money — or rather, the lack of it. Reports allege that Underwood is earning less than half of what Katy Perry made during her time on the show. Perry’s salary reportedly topped $25 million per season.

> “There’s talk Carrie wants more money,” the source added. “She’s wondering if it’s all worth the pain without a nice incentive.”



Given the immense pressure and scrutiny that comes with the high-profile role, it’s easy to understand why Underwood may be feeling conflicted.

What's Next?

At this point, it’s unclear whether Carrie Underwood will return for Season 24 of American Idol. ABC has not yet confirmed the judging panel for the upcoming season, and Underwood herself has not publicly commented on the rumors.

Fans are divided. Some believe she deserves more respect — and a bigger paycheck — while others think the show needs a more energetic presence at the judges’ table.

What do you think? Should Carrie Underwood continue with American Idol, or walk away for good?


---

Let us know your thoughts in the comments below. 👇
📍 Location: Nashville, Tennessee

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Trump’s New Trade Strategy: No Tariffs on Tech – What It Means for You

  Trump’s New Trade Strategy: No Tariffs on Tech – What It Means for You In a major policy update, former President Donald Trump has announced that smartphones, computers, and other consumer electronics will be exempt from the latest round of tariffs on Chinese imports. This move is seen as an attempt to protect American consumers and tech companies from price hikes, especially as the U.S. continues to rely heavily on Chinese-made electronics. While tariffs on other products remain in place, the tech exemption may provide relief for companies like Apple, Dell, and many others. However, questions still remain. The administration is expected to reveal further details on semiconductor tariffs this coming Monday, a sector crucial to both U.S. security and economic growth. Why It Matters: This decision may help keep the prices of everyday gadgets stable. It could ease tensions with major tech firms concerned about global supply chains. The semiconductor policy could define the next chap...
3 comments
Read more

The First Yes: How Mary Began the Story of Jesus

🌟 The First Yes: How Mary Began the Story of Jesus > “Behold, I am the servant of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word.” — Luke 1:38 Before the miracles, the manger, and the message of salvation, the story of Jesus began with a quiet moment — and a simple word: yes. In the small town of Nazareth, lived a young woman named Mary. She was not a queen, not rich, not powerful. She was a humble, devout girl engaged to a man named Joseph. Her days were filled with simplicity — chores, prayer, and preparation for her future marriage. But one ordinary day turned extraordinary. Suddenly, a brilliant light filled her home. Standing before her was Gabriel, an angel of the Lord. He greeted her, not with fear, but with honor: > “Greetings, O favored one. The Lord is with you.” Mary, confused and frightened, listened as Gabriel told her something unimaginable — she would bear a child. Not just any child. A Son of the Most High. She would call Him Jesus. He would be a Ki...
1 comment
Read more